What Multifamily Can Learn from Carvana

By Chris Arnold
Carvana 1

Carvana > Multifamily?

The month after my son was born, we decided it was time to get a newer, safer, and more efficient vehicle for the little one.

I had my marching orders and began searching: low-ish miles, less than 10 years old, and deal-finding as much as possible.

Living up to a Colorado stereotype, a Subaru Outback popped up at a local Audi dealer a mile away.

It was, of course, priced too high.

Otherwise, it was in excellent condition, and it checked all the boxes. I spent the next 10 days negotiating with the rep as both I held out, and he hoped someone would walk in and take the car at the asking price.

Finally, though, we got the car.

And I thought to myself, "that was brutal."

This week, a piece by Tudor Manole keyed off of his recent experience purchasing a vehicle from Carvana. Given the story above, it caught my attention.

Like most marketers, we're always trying to discover new ways to think about and innovate within multifamily by looking outside of multifamily. It's an essential mindset for successful growth in any industry.

His article, in part, speaks to Carvana's approach to transparency*, centralization, and low-touch sales experiences can help multifamily companies reduce burdens in a few ways:

  • with onsite leasing teams
  • by increasing lead quality and conversion rates
  • in reducing the need for in-person showings
  • with flexible payment options
  • via better move-in experiences

However, he notes that multifamily companies rely on multiple, often siloed solutions, which can hinder the renter experience.

For all of you reading, you already know this.

To me, it's a deep well. And the "solution" will eventually involve collaboration between industry technology suppliers.

If we break this down by its parts, we can see that we're talking about a few critical barriers, like:

  • an easy way to scan, source, and purchase an apartment
  • access to updated unit-specific photos
  • low friction purchase ("financing") options
  • a move-in gameplan that reduces tension for everyone
  • an automatic follow-up that encourages communication
  • The list is overwhelming.

It screams, "there's an app for that," but otherwise, it would leave most peoples' heads spinning.

So what is the solution? What can we learn here?

My head immediately goes to segmenting the biggest wins for the renter and working my way backward.

What will move the needle for them the most?

A more seamless purchase experience? Media-rich viewing opportunities? A simple and clear move-in and welcome rollout?

When unraveled in a "parts of the sum" mindset, it becomes a little easier to chip away. But, for better or worse, it's going to remain a company-specific challenge for now.

So ask yourself, what is the biggest source of friction for residents that either grumpily sign a lease or go elsewhere?

If it's media, build better brand and web experiences. Invest in unit-level media, and plant a flag in a UX that dominates your market(s).

If it points back to your leasing team, ask yourself how to refine your team's structure to be a powerhouse in answering questions, finding solutions, and providing options.

To be fair, Carvana has been infused with cash for over a decade and has made timely and strategic purchases to improve its product.

Multifamily isn't a single entity waiting for a surplus of cash, but it can certainly look to what other B2C fixtures are doing to improve the process and reduce time to sale.

Because, after all, the ongoing aim of a more frictionless sale = increased revenue and better ROI for all involved.


*I would be remiss without mentioning that Carvana doesn't have a squeaky clean record. Numerous states have shut them out for illegal titling practices that have misled buyers. It ain't all sunshine and roses at Carvana, especially in the public markets, starting in Q4 2021.

But to use this experience as a representation, I think, goes a long way to get us critically thinking about what multifamily could be to the future renter.

"Do as I say, not as I do," may be appropriate in the tale of Carvana.

Thankfully, regarding tech and renter experience, the story of the multifamily industry is just getting started.

Get Weekly Insights

Latest Insights

Agency onsite teams
Jun 13, 2024

How Agencies and Leasing Teams Can Achieve Synergy

What is the disconnect between marketing and onsite teams in multifamily? There are a few that often dovetail into one another.

TC Investors Listing Image WIDE
Jun 8, 2024

Why Savvy Investors Are Turning To Boutique Apartments

This week, we took a closer look at what makes boutique apartment developments attractive ventures for investors and developers given the current economic landscape and market inventory of 2024. 

Shockingly Meaningful Design Trends
Jun 1, 2024

Meaningful Multifamily Design Trends To Watch

Data reveals three significant design trends and choices that multifamily developers are making to undeniably captivate the modern renters of today.

Centralization multifamily
May 25, 2024

What Is Centralization? The Truth About The Buzzword of 2024

Centralization is undoubtedly one of the multifamily industry’s biggest buzzwords of 2024, sparking discussions among community managers, developers, and investors.

Get the TC:AM Edition

Real estate marketing insights and industry interviews

A simple read in under 5 minutes, delivered to your inbox Saturday mornings.

Subscribe to the TC:AM Edition

A simple read in under 5 minutes, delivered to your inbox Saturday mornings.